Sabtastic's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[A man]

Fantastic job pairing your artwork to this music!

It's very believable, and I appreciate your choices of colour, lighting, and perspective to match the mood. Your focal point is super clear as the idolized subject floating up, and the silouette of the person in the foreground has a pretty clear pose to imply amazement and 'idolizing' body language. This could easily be a cover art piece for a CreoMusic album.

Awesome job and keep up the good work!

[Animu n' Aesthetic]

Awesome job creating a scene to go with such upbeat music!

I definitely see this being a bustling, vibrant downtown scene, and your character (to me) comes off as a believable inhabitant of that environment. Good work with the walking loop, but be sure to follow it through with all the background elements way over from left to right! It cuts off kind of abruptly, which is a tiny bit distracting, but overall I really think you nailed this combination of music and art.

Keep up the good work!

mut3ch4n responds:

Thank you! Yeah, I animated this in Clip Studio Pro so I was kinda limited in how long I could animate it for. I'm definitely considering getting EX for longer projects in the future though, 'cause I agree with your point on the choppiness. Thanks again for the feedback, I'll be sure to keep this in mind the next time I animate something like this!

[Face Them]

Nice work with portraying such a tense, suspenseful scene.
The first few seconds of LucidShadowDreamer's song really match up with what you've painted, and your sunset colour choice really helps to drive the point of a long-standing battleground that's winding to a climactic finale.

Great job ,and keep it up!

BingoWaders responds:

Thank you! Really glad I could get the feeling I wanted across.

[Mushroom Forest Dance]

Great work on combining Seth's song with your art!
I've never tried combining 2D with 3D, but I know it's not easy and super cumbersome.

Visually and audibly I could see these characters existing in a game with this type of music, so you've definitely met the criteria for MIA2020! Awesome job, and keep up the good work.

[Count Them Sheep]

Oooh, awesome job!

Love your linework and colour choices. The application is super neatly done, too.
Is this gouache?

I could easily picture this as an official album cover. It just fits aesthetically with what I'd imagine if this song was brought to life. Nice work with your interpretation and song choice!

BastianConst responds:

Thank-you very much, i am glad you like it.
It is indeed gouache with ink

It was very fun to draw this entry, really enjoyed the contest and seeing other peoples unique takes on songs.

[STAND UP]

Nice job on this piece!

There's a sense of FIERY DETERMINATION behind it and I think your choice of colours adds to the intense energy building up with this character.

The perspective on the stairs don't quite line up with the horizon line, making for a bit of a confusing view, but overall the stairs going up is a pretty logical, understandably frustrating hurdle for your character to face, and I like how you've illustrated this music to match that.

Keep up the good work!

snailpirate responds:

Thanks Sab! I appreciate the review!

[Cyber Space]

Too good!

You've illustrated an entire game to go with this music and it fits together excellently. I'd play this for sure!

The blue color palette stands out as a great choice, in my opinion. The metallic, futuristic, tech vibe I get from the synths really fits with that visually. As for the abstract floating shapes and the perspective implied by the lines, I'd imagine this is a fast-paced platformer, and I think you've suggested that well, too!

Keep up the good work, and great entry!

ryve responds:

Thank you so much :D

[In a Blue Funk]

Awesome job bringing this music to life with your illustration!

I love how you've painted in various metallic / material objects being pelted by rain to emulate the sound effects in this music, and tie everything together. The character appears to be crying, but the music persists as kind of upbeat -- which is a conflicting detail that I think is nice. Rainy days are always a bit glum and gloomy, but there's something nice and distracting about watching them.

If I had to critique anything in particular, (and take this all with a grain of salt, because it looks lovely as is) I would recommend thickening the lines of anything in the foreground to imply that it's closer to the viewer, and thinning the lines of the details in the background. Rain tends to obscure the details of background elements that are far away, making them sort of faded, so less black and thinner lines can help to imply that and create a sense depth! (here's an example of what I mean in an image with heavy rain: https://images.app.goo.gl/3YQTjDsb3kRaALXF6)

All in all, though, I really like your interpretation of this song, and the character you've created. Perfect choice of medium for such a wet environment, too. Lovely work!

TaraGraphika responds:

Thank you Sabtastic for the lovely review and constructive criticism. I'll be sure to remember to add depth duly onward~:)

All the best!~

[Quiet Crossing]

I'm trying not to be biased, but I adore -everything- about this piece.

The music is relaxing, the palette is nice, bright, light and pastel, and the scene you've created goes perfectly with the music you've chosen. The animation loops so nicely, too! If I were browsing around on Youtube looking for something to put on while I worked, I'd definitely pick this.

From a technical standpoint, I really love the cool blue tones vs warm yellows you used in your shadows as the train passes by, and your use of perspective. Everything harmonizes really nicely.

Excellent entry. Keep up the great work!

Karlestonchew responds:

Wow, thank you so much for the kind words and evaluation! This made my week! I knew you'd be judging the art but didn't expect a personalized message. I've been a fan of your art for quite some time now so this really means a lot. Thank you!

[ALL YOUR BASE ARE BELONG TO US]

Dang!

Nice work on bringing the spooky dark vibes of this song to life with your art. You really hit the nail on the head for that part. The spoken parts of the song really sound like they'd be voiced by your grinning cyborg character.

Keep up the good work!